,
Views: 14588,
Hodnocení: pg,
Tags: richard roeper, black swan, natalie portman, mila kunis, movies, review, cinema, film, vincent cassel, barbara hershey, winona ryder, swan lake, ballet, dance, horror, suspense, the red shoes, thriller, transformation, terror, requiem for a dream, the wrestler, the fountain, pi, darren aronofsky,
Richard Roeper reviews Natalie Portman and Mila Kunis in Darren Aronofsky's Black Swan.
Komentáře & Download
Janiel127 - 30.3.2012 1:18:43
they both aint as good as black swan.
JRN2222 - 5.3.2012 9:04:17
People dont understand most of the crazy scenes are within the psychotic mind of Nina, they are filmed in such a way the viewer can feel what Nina is feeling and "thinking" shes seeing.. A psychotic person has such attacks randomly so therefore the film was executed perfectly.. It can be confusing the first time around, but its actually pretty accurate.
JRN2222 - 5.3.2012 8:52:59
Bad review, A to A+ because its up with the greatest films I've ever seen..
ValtronW - 27.2.2012 6:11:49
Oh please, Black Swan is child's play next to Requiem for a Dream.
dkoolscorpionx - 15.2.2012 5:37:10
I can't believe a good crictic like you reviewed black swan so poorly.
It's the second best movie of 2010.
You have made me sick,i trusted your reviews so much but it's all over .
rpmp89 - 1.8.2011 15:43:28
i saw it .....
horrible
check out these movies:lovely bones and hide and seek
IronDonkeyProduction - 14.7.2011 20:19:58
i gotta keep the bar balanced!
dirty06maggot - 1.7.2011 22:50:13
lol glossy camp. i love this movie. love the score too.
PrimaveraPictures - 29.4.2011 16:00:14
I completely agree!
TheOscillat0r - 25.4.2011 8:24:05
B- is exactly what I thought it was. It had great moments of suspense, but at times it came off as cheesy. The acting was perfect, but some of the scenes definitely went in the wrong direction. It's cool to be shocked, but come on. I felt like some scenes ended completely unsatisfactory.
BucsFan2276 - 15.3.2011 4:15:32
DIPSHIT
WalksBehindTheRose - 4.3.2011 19:29:24
i dont usually agree with richard roeper but i think in this review, he's right.
mark33850 - 3.3.2011 16:15:06
And for the black swan I dont see the problems your talking about, maybe you just don't psychological thrillers. but i love them, and i love that movie.
mark33850 - 3.3.2011 16:12:21
Plot holes:
If the dreamer's body's sense of gravity changes and it alters the gravity in their dream, why then does the van's free fall only alter Arthur's gravity in the hotel? Shouldn't the rest of the team suddenly become weightless in the snow covered mountainside (and below)?
Why is Saito such an old man in limbo, whereas Cobb is still young?
How did Mal and Cobb end up in limbo the first time?
How does one wake up from limbo?
Shouldn't Fischer have recognized Saito?
mark33850 - 3.3.2011 16:11:50
Plot holes:
If the dreamer's body's sense of gravity changes and it alters the gravity in their dream, why then does the van's free fall only alter Arthur's gravity in the hotel? Shouldn't the rest of the team suddenly become weightless in the snow covered mountainside (and below)?
Why is Saito such an old man in limbo, whereas Cobb is still young?
How did Mal and Cobb end up in limbo the first time?
How does one wake up from limbo?
Shouldn't Fischer have recognized Saito?
navylaks2 - 2.3.2011 23:57:39
There are no plot holes in Inception if you look extra closely everything makes sence, plus it's one of those films where you can discuss the ending.
Black Swan is about a person who is comepletely obsesed in a crazy way, Portman does a good job full credit to her but i think some of the let's say horror parts of the film were kinda silly.
And just because you´re using a handheld camera dosn't mean that you can't keap it still when you´re focusing it's so annoying and unprofessionel
mark33850 - 2.3.2011 22:40:38
Big mess? Black Swan is perfect in every way, can you please explain how it's a mess.
The problem with Inception is that as it goes into the subconscious, and it questions what reality is and has so many layers to it, that it's an elaborant narative, and plus a couple of big plot holes which creates what is called a mess.
But Inception is the most original film this year I give it that, but it just isn't as good as the Black Swan and other nominated movies.
betharoniboo - 2.3.2011 18:09:26
You have such a way with words.
navylaks2 - 2.3.2011 15:29:47
Black swan is one big mess
Inception had many interesting idears and it never slowed down you where never bored in any scene
They screwed Christopher Nolan once again. Last time it was that stupid slumdog millionaire and Dark Knight wasn't even nominated even though it clearly was the best picture that year.
mark33850 - 2.3.2011 14:49:29
no inception is oveerated, black swan is just perfect, if anything its underated
navylaks2 - 28.2.2011 16:38:37
This movie is just overrated Inception should have won best picture no doubt about it
joanalaiwanna - 15.2.2011 8:30:34
*LACARRA
joanalaiwanna - 15.2.2011 8:24:33
That´s just Natalie Portman, she trained for a year before shooting, so there´s no Lucia Lagarra at all, nor any other ballerina than Natalie Portman playing Nina. So litter, what??
JPoulAndersson - 11.2.2011 20:22:56
Hear, hear! What an utterly magnificent film this is, and equally, what a totally shallow and dumb-witted review this was...rather American. The proper rating ought to be A+ - movies these days seldom come as good!